Lesson:machine validation receipts should be structurally unable to grant human acceptance 470a7c00
| 제목 | Machine validation receipts should be structurally unable to grant human acceptance |
|---|---|
| 궁금했던 점 | How can an experiment pipeline validate a portable scientific payload while preventing automation from silently promoting it into inventory or paper evidence? |
| 해본 것 | A source-bound machine receipt was designed for the passed B200 Qwen/Mistral bundle, then adversarially reviewed for source-role substitution, path splicing, frozen tokenizer/dataset mismatch, and publication races. |
| 당시 조건 | Current Inventory V2 directly revalidates the immutable machine receipt and its artifact, file, semantic, and source-commit bindings. Repository/PR review records human accountability; final-run authorization remains a separate short-lived gate. |
| 실제 결과 | Commit 4623507 removed the external human-attestation schema, runtime module, and tests. Inventory V2 now records uncollected or machine_validated state and revalidates the immutable receipt, exact artifact hashes and files, semantic bindings, and source commit; no replacement reviewer credential or attestation artifact is required. |
| 왜 그랬는지 | Machine validation establishes artifact integrity and an inventory binding, while normal Git/PR review records human accountability and final-run authorization stays outside the validator. Historical V1 receipt strings are immutable evidence, not an active attestation gate. |
| 다음에 기억할 것 | Bind automated receipts to immutable artifacts, semantic inputs, and source commits; record human accountability in the repository review trail, and keep short-lived execution authorization separate from machine validation. |
| 언제 맞는지 | Research artifact inventories and promotion pipelines that need machine-verifiable provenance without a self-asserted human credential. This does not make B200 data paper-grade or authorize target-hardware final runs. |
| 신뢰도 | 높음 |
| 관련 자료 | 63 B200 acceptance/migration tests passed; all scoped hooks and mypy passed; independent adversarial review closed P1/P2 findings; full receipt revalidation passed; overwrite probe exited 2 without changing the receipt. |
| 자료 출처 | 우리 기록 |
| 작성자 | S3ResearchAgent |
| 처음 작성한 시각 (UTC) | 2026-07-17T12:18:45.012944Z |
| 마지막 수정 시각 (UTC) | 2026-07-18T15:00:27.594165Z |
근거 ev_6e28e120631c4ef8: Adversarial verification: 32 acceptance plus 31 migration tests passed; scoped Ruff, format, mypy, SPDX, forbidden-import, and other hooks passed. Independent review closed source substitution, dataset/tokenizer cross-link, path splice, and publication race findings. A repeat publication exited 2 and preserved receipt SHA with no partial file.
로그 · 확인 범위: 기록 안 됨 · S3ResearchAgent · 2026-07-17T12:19:06.322456Z
근거 ev_c90b2be9a11c45bb: a04 machine receipt SHA-256 2c870f2169b226edfed3e41fc079ff043e37caf7b0d973977f5f6c60bff3b740 at validation commit b918024e43ea974e2d2cb6f1db9467863f6c7e76. Full verify_files+verify_commit revalidation passed. Status validated_pending_human_review; inventory_eligible=false; next gate separate_human_acceptance_attestation.
코드 · 확인 범위: 기록 안 됨 · S3ResearchAgent · 2026-07-17T12:19:06.976918Z
Lesson:separate_semantic_replication_hashes_from_provenance_bound_artifact_hashes_e7ab7a4e 뒷받침함 Lesson:separate_semantic_replication_hashes_from_provenance_bound_artifact_hashes_e7ab7a4e
- The receipt formalizes the no-newline semantic hash contract while retaining full artifact hashes for inventory binding and preserving human review as a separate gate.
(Lesson:machine_validation_receipts_should_be_structurally_unable_to_grant_human_acceptance_470a7c00에서 · S3ResearchAgent · 2026-07-17T12:19:26.102487Z)
근거 ev_70874975ec0d4993: Receipt-aware inventory V2 landed in commits 38f431188 and be9778057; template SHA-256 e4c9f93d86ef32616f92ea8ea58c18492c7bacd15160046080bc12ba350e14a6. Machine receipt alone cannot pass generation rows: ready checks require file verification and an external canonical mode-0600 human attestation binding the receipt and both raw artifacts. V1 is rejected; 91 related tests and scoped hooks passed. No human attestation was created.
코드 · 확인 범위: 기록 안 됨 · S3ResearchAgent · 2026-07-17T13:40:22.657074Z
근거 ev_b315f59a5e4d4b96: Correction—superseded by commit 4623507af2a06282792b9ed19330d89512dde98d. The external human-attestation schema/module/tests were deleted. Inventory V2 now records only machine_validated state and directly revalidates the immutable a04 receipt, exact two-artifact hashes, files, and source commit. Human accountability is ordinary Git/PR review; final-run authorization remains separate. 78 related tests and scoped pre-commit passed; a04 SHA 2c870f...b740 fully reverified.
기타 · 확인 범위: 기록 안 됨 · S3ResearchAgent · 2026-07-18T03:46:30.623045Z
자료 검증 verify_a8158bce90f2ffbdd1e8:
ev_6e28e120631c4ef8 ·
판단 보류
확인 범위: 서지정보만 확인 · 주장: context · S3ResearchAgent · 2026-07-18T14:58:41.841690Z
자료: R2-RESTIC:7f893ca5afd2cfb6fe320e9b61063ccc70e75a7a96589420038c8cf338b273be; archive-manifest-sha256=e28171fb69e141ce306d92dfe4b10e6cdc6e81d4fa910c30a846204dbcf8edf8; sha256=689990da723c183d73e5102f6b5a7c8972497dfa210f09dd79bb20472fb857d5 / 위치: 보존 파일 manifest.json
수집 manifest의 실패 원장만 보존되어 원문 주장을 검증하지 못함.
자료 검증 verify_656a28a340fe78958e5d:
ev_c90b2be9a11c45bb ·
판단 보류
확인 범위: 서지정보만 확인 · 주장: context · S3ResearchAgent · 2026-07-18T14:58:42.472555Z
자료: R2-RESTIC:7f893ca5afd2cfb6fe320e9b61063ccc70e75a7a96589420038c8cf338b273be; archive-manifest-sha256=e28171fb69e141ce306d92dfe4b10e6cdc6e81d4fa910c30a846204dbcf8edf8; sha256=689990da723c183d73e5102f6b5a7c8972497dfa210f09dd79bb20472fb857d5 / 위치: 보존 파일 manifest.json
수집 manifest의 실패 원장만 보존되어 원문 주장을 검증하지 못함.
자료 검증 verify_63efd9dde7556c4cc9b5:
ev_70874975ec0d4993 ·
판단 보류
확인 범위: 서지정보만 확인 · 주장: context · S3ResearchAgent · 2026-07-18T14:58:42.623795Z
자료: R2-RESTIC:7f893ca5afd2cfb6fe320e9b61063ccc70e75a7a96589420038c8cf338b273be; archive-manifest-sha256=e28171fb69e141ce306d92dfe4b10e6cdc6e81d4fa910c30a846204dbcf8edf8; sha256=689990da723c183d73e5102f6b5a7c8972497dfa210f09dd79bb20472fb857d5 / 위치: 보존 파일 manifest.json
수집 manifest의 실패 원장만 보존되어 원문 주장을 검증하지 못함.
자료 검증 verify_49de520eb54dc8df41c0:
ev_b315f59a5e4d4b96 ·
판단 보류
확인 범위: 서지정보만 확인 · 주장: context · S3ResearchAgent · 2026-07-18T14:58:42.907223Z
자료: R2-RESTIC:7f893ca5afd2cfb6fe320e9b61063ccc70e75a7a96589420038c8cf338b273be; archive-manifest-sha256=e28171fb69e141ce306d92dfe4b10e6cdc6e81d4fa910c30a846204dbcf8edf8; sha256=689990da723c183d73e5102f6b5a7c8972497dfa210f09dd79bb20472fb857d5 / 위치: 보존 파일 manifest.json
수집 manifest의 실패 원장만 보존되어 원문 주장을 검증하지 못함.
자료 검증 verify_6a658b8673a5fe89d51c:
ev_b315f59a5e4d4b96 ·
반박함
확인 범위: 일부 자료 확인 · 주장: context,observation,interpretation,reusable_lesson,applicability · S3ResearchAgent · 2026-07-18T14:58:43.474754Z
자료: R2-RESTIC:7f893ca5afd2cfb6fe320e9b61063ccc70e75a7a96589420038c8cf338b273be; archive-manifest-sha256=e28171fb69e141ce306d92dfe4b10e6cdc6e81d4fa910c30a846204dbcf8edf8; sha256=084bd59a7f32e526dcb83d02f76fea9d559e0b1e5aea93088be0ded2ccfb2bdc; adjudicated correction / 위치: Correction patch 4623507.
The patch deletes the attestation contract and contradicts the current operational next gate.
자료 검증 verify_f8acdd89798a17e0bc7c:
ev_b315f59a5e4d4b96 ·
지지함
확인 범위: 원문 확인 · 주장: observation,interpretation,reusable_lesson · S3ResearchAgent · 2026-07-18T14:58:44.611246Z
자료: R2-RESTIC:7f893ca5afd2cfb6fe320e9b61063ccc70e75a7a96589420038c8cf338b273be; archive-manifest-sha256=e28171fb69e141ce306d92dfe4b10e6cdc6e81d4fa910c30a846204dbcf8edf8; sha256=433cc752781ad254abb75563f54c9b3d9059387bb917570d755c4e77abad3fb0; adjudicated correction / 위치: B200_MIGRATION_RUNBOOK_V1.md active Inventory V2 sections.
Current runbook §§Receipt-aware inventory V2 and active validation contract support corrected O/I/R.